The Costly Wish
Logline
Seven spine tingling chapters weaving three main characters through unearthed secrets in 82 pages. Not written for the faint of heart.
Genre
Suspense/Thriller,Young Adult,Horror,Mystery
Short Summary
From a narrated point of view-Maggie returns home after the unexpected death of her husband. Arriving at her parents home with her two children she discovers secrets and has to face the truth so ugly and terrifying that it will challenge all she holds so close and dear.
There is another follow on book of the series- but this one does end with Maggie learning about her family's possession to include her children and the lengths to which she will go to keep them protected.
Setting
Southern town of Oxford, Mississippi
Based on a True Story
No
Plot - Premise
Tragedy
Plot - Other Elements
Twist
Mature Audience Themes
Substance Abuse,Extreme Violence
Main Character Details
Name: Maggie
Age: 30's
Gender: Female
Role: Emotional
Key Traits: Naive,Romantic,Heroic,Modest,Faithful,Empathetic
Additional Character Details
Name: Momma C
Age: 70's
Gender: Female
Role: Logical
Key Traits: Badass,Charming,Confident,Decisive,Engaging,Heroic,Educated,Leader,Secretive,Skillful,Outspoken
Additional Character Details
Name: Bramlett
Age: 30's
Gender: Male
Role: mentor
Key Traits: Masculine,Modest,Selfless,Skillful,Secretive,Honorable,Heroic,Heartthrob,Empathetic
Additional Character Details
The author has not yet written this
Development Pitch
Maggie returns home to seek refuge only to discover a truth so terrifying that it will challenge all she holds so close and dear.
Genre
SUSPENSE, THRILLER, DRAMA
Brief
Maggie's husband dies and she is forced to move back in with her mother and their two young kids. The grandmother, Momma C, gives the children protective necklaces. She reveals to Maggie that she has been talking to spirits that helped get revenge for their husbands deaths. Maggie's brother returns and they fear Momma C is making blood sacrifices in order to keep them safe.
Overall Rating
FAIR
Narrative Elements
Authors Writing Style: FAIR
Characterization: FAIR
Commerciality: FAIR
Franchise Potential: GOOD
Pace: FAIR
Premise: FAIR
Structure: FAIR
Theme: FAIR
Accuracy of Book Profile
The book somewhat reflects the narrative. The development pitch is better suited as a logline and the logline could be part of the development pitch. The development pitch could benefit from being lengthened to include themes to help express why the story is unique and marketable. The profile also mentions that there is 82 pages when the file is only 33 pages.
Draw of Story
It is suspicious why the grandmother is so fixated on strawberries and seems more concerned about everyone wearing their necklaces rather than what is causing her daughter to be so ill. Giving Momma C irrational fears but not making her afraid of what everyone else is creates tension that she knows more than she is telling.
Possible Drawbacks
There are jumps in the pacing and chronology of events that make the plot somewhat hard to follow. For example when the brother returns and Maggie shares what Momma C did but it mainly skips over the story cutting to his reaction. The pacing can be too fast at times so showing instead of telling could even this out.
Use of Special Effects
THE STORY RELIES A LITTLE BIT ON SPECIAL EFFECTS
Primary Hook of Story
The hook is that the grandmother's husband and son-in-law were both murdered and she uses witchcraft to protect her family and seek revenge.
Fanbase Potential
With further character development this could have a decent audience for fans of horror movies as there is a neat dynamics of antagonism. It is not clear if the grandmother is helping or harming her family in a morally grey type of tension.
Awards Potential
Due to the horror genre this is unlikely to win any prestige awards but might be commercially popular.
Envisioned Budget
MEDIUM BUDGET
Similar Films/TV Series
AMERICAN HORROR STORY, PRACTICAL MAGIC, THE CONJURING, GRETEL & HANSEL, HEREDITARY
What’s New About the Story
The antagonist possibly being the grandmother is compelling but refining her motivation as well as adding depth to the other characters outside of just reactions could help make the interactions feel more dynamic.
Lead Characters
Momma C is confident, protective and a bit misguided. Maggie is confused, compliant but also caring. Bramlett is inquisitive, cynical and direct.
Uniqueness of Story
Creating clear inner conflicts for the characters and connecting the flashbacks more clearly to the main conflict could help create a pacing and structure that is easier to follow.
Possible Formats
Film: Streaming, Indie TV Series: Streaming, Limited Run / Mini-Series
Analyst Recommendation
WORK IN PROGRESS
Justification
While the story has many positive points, it has room for improvement (see possible paths below). If you can't change the story at this point, my suggestion is using your notes as a guide to highlight the best aspects of it when taking the next steps, either putting a pitch page together, a treatment, or a presentation.
Tips for Improvement
Creating more depth and clear motivation and inner conflicts for the characters would help create further emotional investment for the plot. Making sure the subplots are clearly connected to the main conflict and providing a more linear timeline could also help slow down the pacing and create a structure that is easier to follow.